Case file #1
DONAGHY
Filed under sports corruption, 2000s.
- Era
- 2000s (2007)
- Date
- July 20
- Status
- Closed
Spoilers ahead
This page tells the whole case, including how it ended. It concerns real deaths and real people, and it is written under our editorial standards. Play the case first, or read on when you are ready.
Read the case file
The case came out of the FBI's Gambino crime family squad in New York. A confidential informant reported in October 2006 that an NBA referee was compromised, and agents traced phone records through a network of Brooklyn gamblers until the referee resolved to Tim Donaghy. The tip predated the scheme it exposed: Donaghy had been betting on games, including his own, through a friend since about the 2003-04 season, and only in December 2006 was he recruited by professional gambler James Battista, with Thomas Martino relaying picks and cash. He pleaded guilty on August 15, 2007 before Judge Carol Bagley Amon, who sentenced him to fifteen months in July 2008 and called him more culpable than his co-defendants: "Without Mr. Donaghy, there was no scheme." Restitution to the league totalled $217,266.94, far below the $1.4 million the NBA sought. The record correction: the government's own sentencing filing states that "there is no evidence that Donaghy ever intentionally made a particular ruling during a game in order to increase the likelihood that his gambling pick would be correct." What Donaghy acknowledged was subtler and, for a referee, arguably worse: that he had "compromised his objectivity as a referee because of his personal financial interest in the outcome of NBA games, and that this personal interest might have subconsciously affected his on-court performance." The NBA's independent review by Lawrence Pedowitz found no evidence any other referee bet on games or leaked information, and no evidence the league directs outcomes; it did not affirmatively clear Donaghy of altering calls either, saying only that it could not contradict the government's conclusion. A 2019 ESPN statistical investigation argued he did manipulate calls; no official body has adopted that conclusion, and Donaghy has always denied it.
Read about how we handle cases like this one in our editorial standards.